26 September 2008
Dating websites are booming – and if their popularity is anything to go by, the internet must be very good at matchmaking. Five million singles are apparently waiting, “just for you”, on Dating Direct (catchphrase “same game new rules”). Match.com can “make love happen”, and has matchmakers on hand ready to pair you off. For the more focused dater, there’s Friends Reunited Dating or Online Dating for Single Parents – or even TV personality Sarah Beeny’s online dating website, Mysinglefriend.com.
Mirroring this upsurge, more and more matching services for investors and entrepreneurs are springing up. The 2007 launch of Angels Den was followed last month by the opening of Venture Giants: and on the international stage, last year’s launch of pan-European network Easy followed in the footsteps of AngelSoft, which was founded in 2004 by legendary New York investor David Rose. According to Angel Investor magazine, there are estimated to be upwards of a dozen matching services in the UK alone,
Sitra, the Finnish Innovation Fund was one of the founding members of the EBAN. Venture Giants met with Risto Kalske to discuss how the acclaimed PreSeed concept got started.
The matching of investors and couples bears many similarities – both sides often struggle to seek each other out, they each find a neutral venue like a website a less intimidating environment to flaunt their “wares”, and in both instances a certain amount of “filtering” is required before the actual, ahem, transaction can be completed. Angels Den even holds popular speed dating events. But it’s fair to say that investor matching services, like dating websites, have so far enjoyed a somewhat patchy reputation.
When asked his opinion on matching services, Nick Halstead, founder of blog aggregator and g2i company Favorit, is none too complimentary about angel networks: “My experience with angel networks has been ‘avoid unless you have to’. When I first raised money, I ignored all of them. In fact, at a lot of the networking events I went to, I started to see them as sharks.”
He does concede that there are good and bad matching services, but categorises one of the larger networks as “big but terrible. I used them in a previous company and they just spam out your plan and take your money.”
The good, the bad and the ugly:
The raison d’etre of these sites is that they take the legwork out of contacting multiple angels to piece together a funding round. The latest set of figures from the National Endowment for Science, Technology and the Arts (Nesta) shows the level of investment from both the early-stage VC market and angel investors to be erratic, although in both cases there’s been a general trend towards a larger number of smaller deals, and an increased level of co-investment, whether that be with public funds, or, increasingly, other angel investors.
According to Nesta’s September report, “Shifting Sands: The changing nature of the early stage venture capital market in the UK”, investments below £2 million accounted for between 70% and 80% of all venture capital investments between 2001 and 2007. However, the average investment shrank sharply between 2002 and 2006, from £700,000 to £393,000, although it recovered in 2007 to £705,000. What this skewing means is that entrepreneurs are increasingly having to piece together deals from a number of different sources.
That trend is only likely to continue as sources of finance dry up in the credit crunch. Rishi Anand, founder of Venture Giants and a successful entrepreneur himself, says: “It’s a difficult process. When I first started, I remember how much running around I had to do. The site is just a way to develop leads and contacts, to create a dialogue and keep in contact. If you don’t use it, then you’re restricted to friends and family and your own network of contacts.”
So why do competing businesses have such a poor reputation among entrepreneurs? In some cases, complaints about the performance of matching services stem from the fact that people expect too much from them – Anand himself points out that Venture Giants is no replacement for old-fashioned networking, but rather complements it. He further continues, that said, criticism of the matching services come from three main areas: first, that the networks usually take an upfront fee, regardless of their success; second, that they often apply only limited sophistication to the matching service; and third, that there’s a lack of transparency, which makes it difficult to know where you’re going wrong with your proposition.
To many, the upfront fee feels rather like the fee you would pay for taking out a classified ad in a local newspaper. It’s got a low price tag compared to, say, a page of display advertising, but you don’t really know who’s going to see it or what impact it might have. That said, there are some differences between the services on offer. Angels Den, for example, charges a one-off fee of £99, while Venture Giants charges the same figure, but only when you’ve been contacted by an investor. "We’ve changed the business model to pay on performance,” says Anand. “In today’s economic climate, I would not take money upfront for any service.”
Rishi Anand also believes it’s the filtering of entrepreneurs and investors that lies at the heart of the proposition. Investors who sign up to Venture Giants fill in a self-certification form which indicates the minimum and maximum amount they are looking to invest, and which industry and region they’re interested in. Entrepreneurs’ regions, industry types, investment range and expectations are then matched to investors and an introduction effected.
Halstead agrees this is an important component of the service: “The good networks put more work into the filtering process on both sides so that the final meet is more focused on the right matching. Too many angel networks require you to pay up front.”
Anand insists that because Venture Giants only takes a fee once an entrepreneur has been contacted, it’s more reliant on the quality of its database. He points out that high net worth individuals are difficult to define and even harder to find – he hired consultants to extrapolate data on millionaires or individuals with strong shareholdings and invite them to join. Only two weeks in, he already has 127 registrations from entrepreneurs with limited marketing – and other networks report similarly high levels of interest.
Ultimately, any investor grouping is only as good as the quality of investors in the network. They should be judged by the investments that have been made as a result of their match making, so it’s always worth checking out their track record. Unlike dating, there’s little pleasure in the dalliance between an investor and entrepreneur – so you do want to use a service that stands a good chance of getting the whole thing sorted out quickly.
Would you be willing to invest in a software start-up from India? A property development in Bulgaria? Is investing abroad viable for a business angel investor? The following article explores this growing angel investment phenomena.
Another dilemna most Angel Investors will have to deal with is which is it better to focus on?
Investing in your own entrepreneurial creativity or investing in another's entrepreneurial creativity - the following article deals with this topic, and why it is so important to find balance in your angel investments.
What is g2i?
g2i is a highly successful investment readiness programme delivering early stage private investment to exciting young businesses.
The gateway2investment (g2i) programme is designed to maximise the success of London based companies raising private investment. Delivered by a consortium of private sector specialists, g2i offers advice, support and assistance to help companies develop their teams, propositions and pitches. g2i offers you the opportunity to work with experienced entrepreneurs and investors to become 'investor ready'.
Business Funding available at Venture Giants. We are a premier UK business Angel investment network and small to mid sized business networking portal that matches active business angel investors with entrepreneurs' seeking angel investment capital and business funding.
Follow Venture Giants on Twitter